Sept 22,
2006 How low
can you go?
Sign
on today and support a monthly minimum wage of Tk3000
(€34.37) for Bangladeshi garment workers
Garment workers have been participating in rallies
and demonstrations across Bangladesh since the beginning
of September to protest against the failure of the
Bangladesh Wage Board to come up with an acceptable
minimum wage for the garment industry. The CCC supports
the workers in their demand for a wage that allows
them to live in dignity. Your support is needed
to pressure the Bangladesh garment factory associations
to set a wage that will genuinely improve the lives
of these workers. We also ask you to send a message
to the international brands and retailers buying
from Bangladesh to voice their support for workers'
demand to be paid a living wage and put this into
practice.
Take Action Now! >>
Background - Minimum wage
currently just €10.75 per month The
current minimum wage for garment workers, fixed
around twelve years ago, stands at 930 Bangladeshi
Taka (Tk), equivalent to just €10.75 or US$13.63
per month - one of the lowest in the world. Whilst
garment workers and their supporters have been
demanding wage increases for several years it
wasn't until May 2006, following the outbreak
of massive labour unrest by workers unable to
tolerate the extreme exploitative conditions any
longer, that any kind of action was taken by the
Bangladesh government.
One of the main demands of the protesting workers
was for immediate action on the issue of wages.
In response to this the Bangladesh government
announced the formation of a tripartite Minimum
Wage Board for the garment industry on May 31st
2006.
The Wage Board, which includes representatives
of the garment workers' unions and the Bangladeshi
garment industry, first met on June 12th 2006
and was asked to recommend a new pay scale for
garment workers within 90 days. Neither the Bangladesh
Garment Manufacturers' Association (BGMEA) nor
workers' representative on the Wage Board signed
a proposal sent by the Board on September 12th
to the government to set the wage rate for entry
level workers at Tk1,604 in the first year up
to June 30 leading to Tk2,117 in the third year
starting from July, 2008. The workers' representative
felt this rate was too low, but the BGMEA felt
it is too high. The Wage Board proposal must be
kept in circulation until September 28th for opinions
and objectives, and the government will take another
month for its approval.
Workers are demanding Tk3,000 (€35.53) as
the minimum wage for entry-level workers. The
CCC has compiled five key arguments as to why
we believe a wage increase to Tk 3000 is absolutely
essential.
- The garment industry has grown enormously
since 1994 when the current minimum wage was
set and so should the minimum wage.
- In real terms, wages have gone down since
the last minimum wage was set twelve years ago.
- The current minimum wage does not even cover
the cost of food for one person.
- The proposed wage doesn't meet the United
Nations Millennium Development Goals to eradicate
extreme poverty and hunger and therefore violates
basic human rights.
- Increasing the minimum wage by itself won't
make the Bangladeshi garment industry un-competitive
Find more explanation of these arguments below.
Action RequestBangladeshi
workers need your support, take action now!
- Register your solidarity with the Bangladeshi
garment workers' demands by signing the online
petition at: http://www.bgw-info.net/solidarity/frmsolidarity.php
- Write to the garment factory
owners' associations BGMEA and BKMEA and
ask them to agree to the workers' demand (see
sample letter below).
- Write to brands and retailers
buying from Bangladesh, asking them to state
their willingness to continue sourcing from
Bangladesh and ensure that their prices and
purchasing practices allow factories to pay
at least Tk3,000 for entry-level workers. Buyers
should urge the government to reconsider the
latest proposal of the Wage Board in favour
of a Tk3,000 rate. Meanwhile, irrespective of
the decision of the Wage Board the buyers should
also make sure that workers producing their
garments earn a living wage as stipulated in
many codes of conduct; according to most calculations
this would be considerably higher than the Tk3,000
workers demand. (See sample letter below.)
Bangladesh
wages: Five arguments why garment workers' wages
must be increased
September 2006
'I get Tk 900 for a month of hard labour
which is not enough to even cover my food bills,'
said a worker at Tejgaon.
'Can you show me one worker who runs his
family without a hitch with the money he gets?'
asked Sagar, who works in SS Sweater for a monthly
salary of Tk 950,(1) .
1. The garment industry has grown
enormously since 1994 when the current minimum
wage was set and so should the minimum wage
When the minimum wage was last adjusted in 1994
the value of the ready-made garment (RMG) sector
was US$1.5 billion, up from $68,000 in 1978. Between
1994 and 2006, this grew to US$7.04 billion, four
and a half times the value in 1994. Factory owners
are now predicting that the industry will grow
even further: "We're confident we can now
keep the growth momentum intact and double our
exports to more than 15 billion dollars in the
next five years," S. M. Fazlul Hoque, president
of the Bangladesh Garments Manufacturers and Exporters
Association told reporters in Dhaka.(2)
After 25 years of operation the industry is one
of the biggest export sectors in the country,
making up 75% of Bangladesh's export earnings.
Whilst the industry has grown, wages have remained
the same, even though minimum wage levels set
for garment workers in 1994 were low to begin
with, far below the cost of living, and far below
wages in other labour/industrial sectors.
Garment factory owners and international buyers
have profited from the garment industry and seen
their incomes rise - workers have not. Garment
workers, the poorest players in the industry,
should no longer have to subsidize its growth.
2. In real terms, wages have gone
down since the last minimum wage was set twelve
years ago
Jakir Hossain of Bangladeshi think-tank Unnayan
Onneshan, showed at a roundtable on 'National
Minimum Wage: Poverty Reduction and Social Justices
for Workers' on August 24, 2006, that due to currency
inflation and increase in commodity prices the
minimum wage should be Tk4,286, if it is to meet
the basic needs of workers. (3)
In 2005, the Bangladesh government declared a
minimum wage of Tk 2450 (basic wages without allowances
and benefits) for workers in state-owned industries.
There is no reason why garment workers shouldn't
get the same wages as other workers.
3. The current minimum wage does
not even cover the cost of food for one person
A recent calculation by a Bangladesh NGO states
that whilst the costs may vary depending on where
a worker works and lives, a single garment worker
needs to spend a total of Tk2,150 - 3,350 just
to fulfil basic needs: Tk350-700 for house rent,
Tk1,000-1,200 for food, Tk200-300 for transportation,
Tk100-200 for washing, Tk150-250 for buying cloths
and cosmetics, Tk150-200 for entertainment and
recreation and Tk200-500 for medicine.
According to M. K. Shefali, executive director
of Nari Uddug Kendra: 'For an adult living in
Dhaka city the minimum nutrition requirement for
basic living is 1,805 calorie per day. At today's
costs of living this means Tk1,400 (US$21.54)
per person per month for food alone. Many garment
workers (particularly female) do not earn this
amount, which is severely affecting their health
as well as productivity." (4)
The Bangladesh Institute for Labour Services
(BILS) conducted a study in summer 2006 into a
living wage, which was calculated by the research
team in various ways. The main consideration was
the minimum cost of living of a family of four,
which was calculated to be Tk 4,800 per month.
(5)
4. The proposed wage doesn't meet
the United Nations Millennium Development Goal
to eradicate extreme poverty and hunger and therefore
violates basic human rights
One of the United Nations' Millennium Development
Goals is to eradicate extreme poverty and hunger.
The first target for this goal is to halve, between
1990 and 2015, the proportion of people whose
income is less than one dollar a day. A person
who is earning less than US$1 a day is considered
to be living in extreme poverty without adequate
food, shelter, medicine, etc. By fixing the minimum
wage at anything less than Tk2,114, (6)garment
workers will be forced to live in poverty, which
amounts to a serious violation of basic human
rights. The current Wage Board proposal does not
meet this standard, nor does the Tk1,300 proposed
by BGMEA
5. Increasing the minimum
wage by itself won't make the Bangladeshi garment
industry un-competitive
The Bangladesh minimum wage for garment workers
is amongst the lowest in the world. Even tripling
the minimum wage will still keep Bangladesh garment
workers amongst the lowest paid in the world.
Indeed improving conditions for workers including
wages is essential for increasing the competitiveness
of the Bangladeshi garment industry. As the MFA
Forum (7)in May 2006 in Dhaka,
Bangladesh concluded:
"There is now acknowledgement that compliance
with national law and international labour standards
is a vital component of international competitiveness
and the sustainability of the industry".
Sample letter to the BGMEA
/ BKMEA
Fazlul Hoque, President, BGMEA
Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association
FAX: 880-2-8113951
E-mail: info@bgmea.com,
bgmeanet@agni.com
Fazlul Hoque, President, BKMEA
Bangladesh Knitwear Manufacturers and Exporters
Association
Fax: 880-2-9673337
E-mail: fhoque@bangla.net
Dear Mr Hoque and Mr Hoque,
Re: Garment Factory Workers' Wages
I am writing to express my support for the Bangladeshi
garment workers who are calling for a minimum
wage of Tk3,000 per month based on the following
arguments:
- The garment industry has grown enormously
since 1994 when the current minimum wage was
set and so should the minimum wage.
- In real terms, wages have gone down since
the last minimum wage was set twelve years ago.
- The current minimum wage does not even cover
the cost of food for one person.
- The proposed wage doesn't meet the United
Nations Millennium Development Goals to eradicate
extreme poverty and hunger and therefore violates
basic human rights.
- Increasing the minimum wage itself won't make
the Bangladeshi garment industry un-competitive
The Bangladesh minimum wage for garment workers
is amongst the lowest in the world. Even tripling
the minimum wage will still keep Bangladesh garment
workers amongst the lowest paid in the world.
Indeed improving conditions for workers including
wages is essential for increasing the competitiveness
of the Bangladeshi garment industry. As the MFA
Forum (8) in May 2006 in
Dhaka, Bangladesh concluded
"There is now acknowledgement that compliance
with national law and international labour standards
is a vital component of international competitiveness
and the sustainability of the industry".
(9)
I call on you to take immediate action to see
that the minimum wage for garment workers is increased
to Tk3,000.
For your information I am also contacting the
brands in my country that produce garments in
Bangladesh to convey my concerns and request that
they take action. Please keep me informed of the
steps you take to follow up on this serious matter.
Yours sincerely
[Your name]
Sample letter to brands
You can use this letter to send to brands in your
country you think may be sourcing from Bangladesh.
Dear xxx
I understand that you may be sourcing garments
from Bangladesh. If you are not, please accept
this letter for information only.
I am writing to express my support for the Bangladeshi
garment workers who are calling for a minimum
wage of Tk3000 (€35.53) per month based on
the following arguments:
- The garment industry has grown enormously
since 1994 when the current minimum wage was
set and so should the minimum wage.
- In real terms, wages have gone down since
the last minimum wage was set twelve years ago.
- The current minimum wage does not even cover
the cost of food for one person.
- The proposed wage doesn't meet the United
Nations Millennium Development Goals to eradicate
extreme poverty and hunger and therefore violates
basic human rights.
- 5. Increasing the minimum wage by itself won't
make the Bangladeshi garment industry un-competitive.
The Bangladesh minimum wage for garment workers
is amongst the lowest in the world. Even tripling
the minimum wage will still keep Bangladesh garment
workers amongst the lowest paid in the world.
Indeed improving conditions for workers including
wages is essential for increasing the competitiveness
of the Bangladeshi garment industry. As the MFA
Forum (10) in May 2006 in
Dhaka, Bangladesh concluded
"There is now acknowledgement that compliance
with national law and international labour standards
is a vital component of international competitiveness
and the sustainability of the industry".
Bearing this in mind, I call on you to:
- state your willingness to continue sourcing
from Bangladesh and ensure that your prices
and purchasing practices allow factories to
pay at least Tk3,000 for entry-level workers;
- urge the Bangladesh government to reconsider
the latest proposal of the Wage Board in favour
of a Tk3,000 rate;
- make sure that workers producing garments
for your company earn a living wage, irrespective
of the decision of the Wage Board; according
to most calculations a living wage would be
considerably higher than the Tk3000 workers
demand.
I look forward to hearing what steps you have
taken.
Yours sincerely
[Your name]
Notes
- "Labour leaders put unrest down to years
of deprivation" in New Age May 24, 2006
http://www.newagebd.com/2006/may/24/front.html
- September 3rd, 2006 http://www.dawn.com/2006/09/03/ebr12.htm
- Minimum wage for garment sector by 1st week
of Oct, Thu, 24 Aug 2006, New Nation
http://www.bgw-info.net/news/news.php?page=details&news=220
- Page 46, Institutions and Pro-Poor Growth
in Bangladesh: IPPG Inception Phase Study' by
Chatterjee, Davis, Eusuf, John Harriss, Purohit
June 2006 http://www.lse.ac.uk/collections/IPPG/PDF/IPPG%20WorkingPaper/
IPPGWP2BangladeshCaseStudyBCHATTERJEEetalJune2006.pdf
- E-mail correspondence August 27, 2006.
- Based on an exchange rate of one dollar =
Tk69.0876
- The MFA Forum brings together international
brands and retailers, trade unions, non-governmental
organizations (NGOs), international institutions
and donors and collaborates with national governments,
local industry and civil society.
- The MFA Forum brings together international
brands and retailers, trade unions, non-governmental
organizations (NGOs), international institutions
and donors and collaborates with national governments,
local industry and civil society.
- Page 23, MFA Conference Report: "Forum
on the Future II: A Responsible and Competitive
RMG Sector in Bangladesh", Dhaka, 2-3 May
2006
- The MFA Forum brings together international
brands and retailers, trade unions, non-governmental
organizations (NGOs), international institutions
and donors and collaborates with national governments,
local industry and civil society.