(Background: August
22, 1999, Nicaragua: case of fired Union leaders at Chih Hsing)
10 Apr 2001, Unions and the Chentex Factory in Nicaragua!
Dear Friends, Please find below an update on the ongoing case
at the Chentex factory in Nicaragua, provided by the Campaign
for Labor Rights in the United States. Note the action request
included in this update.
In this Bulletin:
- Victory at Chentex factory in Nicaragua-Court rules that union
leaders must be reinstated to their jobs.
- Factory Owners Threaten to Cut-and-Run-Nien Hsing
representative says factory will close.
- Call to Action-fax action to pressure Chentex
to comply with court ruling and not to cut-and-run from Nicaragua.
{Information in this CLR Labor Bulletin provided by Nicaragua Network,
CENIDH, and Witness for Peace}
Victory at Chentex Factory in Nicaragua!
On Wednesday April 4th at 9:15 am, the Managua Court of Appeals,
in a 2 to 1 decision, ruled in favor of Chentex union leaders in
their third and final legal appeal to be reinstated to their jobs.
Pedro Ortega, General Secretary of the Textile and Garment Workers'
Federation (CST-JBE), congratulated the union and the international
campaign stating, "This is a victory for us all."
The case was brought before the court by the Nicaraguan Center
for Human Rights (CENIDH) in support of the fired union officers
at Chentex Garment Factory in Managua's Las Mercedes Free Trade
Zone. The Court ruled that all nine union officers be rehired to
their original posts within three days and that they receive 100%
of their back pay for the nine months that they have been without
work. The Nicaraguan Labor Code prohibits the firing of union officers
during collective bargaining negotiations or during a strike resulting
from the breakdown of those negotiations.
Bayardo Izaba, an attorney with CENIDH who has been working on
the case, stated that this was a final ruling, and it cannot be
appealed under Nicaraguan law. Furthermore, Izaba explained that,
if the Chentex management does not comply with the order within
three days, the factory's assets could be seized.
However, Chentex legal advisor, Doris Escalona, stated that the
company will file a "recurso de aclaracion," which is
a kind of injunction placed on the court's decision asking the court
to explain its ruling. The recurso is viewed by the unionists as
a stall tactic that will buy the company time before being forced
to reinstate them. The nine union leaders plan to re-enter the factory
at 7:00am on Monday morning (April 9). But the recurso may pose
an obstacle for them: Next week marks the beginning of Semana Santa
(holy week), meaning most Nicaraguan businesses and government offices
will be closed. Because of the Semana Santa holiday, the court may
not review Chentex's injunction until the middle of the following
week. [See the call to action below to find out how you can support
the leaders in their attempt to re-enter the factory on Monday.]
Gladys Manzanares, an official of the Chentex union was elated
about the union's victory. She is among the union leaders being
re-instated, and she said of returning to the factory, "Our
first goal is to get the hundreds of other union workers who were
fired last year re-hired to the factory." She reports that
she and the rest of the union leadership are excited to begin working
toward negotiating a wage increase as well as improvements in health
and safety inside the factory.
Gladys Manzanares and Pedro Ortega both claim that, "It has
been a strategy of the union to ask some of our supporters within
the factory to renounce the union so they would not be fired. In
this way, we have been able to keep strength within the factory
that will surface when the union leadership goes back to work."
Chentex Owners Threaten to Cut-and-Run
The court's ruling came on the same day on which the union and
management were to meet to sign an agreement. This agreement would
have meant the rehiring of only two of the fired union officers
along with twenty other fired workers out of 700 who were fired
over several months during 2000. [For more background on the Chentex
struggle, check Campaign for Labor Rights web site: http://www.summersault.com/~agj/clr
The meeting where the agreement was to be signed still took place
at 5:00pm in the Intercontinental Hotel-hours after the court had
announced its decision. In attendance were; Nien Hsing Consortium
(owners of Chentex) representative Lucas Huang, consortium legal
counsel Doris Escalona, Chentex manager Carlos Yin, Garment Workers
Federation General Secretary Pedro Ortega, and Harling Bobadilla
and Santiago Villalobos of the Chentex union, among others.
Pedro Ortega reported, "The meeting was very tense. Lucas
Huang said that he would not obey the court's ruling. Doris Escalona
said that the company would activate the criminal charges against
the union officers in the Seventh District Criminal Court of Managua."
These criminal charges were to be dropped as a part of the agreement
that would have been signed at that meeting.
Pedro Ortega explained to the Chentex delegation that the court's
ruling was considered a victory for the Chentex workers and for
the international solidarity campaign in the U.S. and Taiwan. "There
is no appeal to this ruling", he told Lucas Huang, "Management
has to obey it."
Ortega reports that, during the discussion at the meeting, "Lucas
Huang became extremely upset. He went so far as to threaten to close
the Chentex factory."
According to Nicaraguan law, Chentex would have to gain permission
to close the factory from the Nicaraguan Ministry of Labor by proving
reasons of financial hardship. If Chentex does not follow this law
or the recent court ruling, Nien Hsing (Chentex owners) will lose
their assets to the government.
Call to Action: Send faxes to Chentex to pressure them to comply
with the court ruling and not to cut-and-run!
Campaign for Labor Rights, along with Witness for Peace, Quest
for Peace, US/Labor Education in the Americas Project, and the Nicaragua
Network have sent out press releases to all media outfits in Nicaragua
praising the court's ruling and encouraging Chentex to comply with
it. The idea is that, by generating press coverage in Nicaragua,
we may help pressure the Chentex management to comply with the court
and allow the nine union leaders to be re-instated.
Campaign for Labor Rights also mobilized its Labor Defense Network
today to add to the pressure on Chentex.
The following fax was sent with the signatures of the LDN's 276
subscribers. [For information on the LDN check the Campaign for
Labor Rights web site.]
More pressure will be needed to make sure that:
1. The Chentex management allows the nine union leaders to enter
the factory on Monday as ruled by the court. 2. Nien Hsing does
not close the Chentex factory and move their jeans production to
another site.
**Action: Send faxes to the Nien Hsing headquarters in Taiwan.
Fax #: 886-37-728361
Sample fax:
Ron Chu Chen, CEO Nien Hsing Textile Co., LTD.
Dear Mr. Chen,
As a labor rights supporter, I have been following the situation
at the Chentex factory in Managua, Nicaragua. Over the last months
I have been very concerned about the labor rights violations that
have occurred in the Chentex factory and have participated in the
international campaign to support the workers' right to organize
a union.
Today, I am writing to express my profound support of the recent
ruling by the Managua Court of Appeals that Chentex must rehire
nine of the leaders of the Chentex workers' struggle. As a consumer
and an activist for human rights, I would appreciate your compliance
with this court decision. This has been a long struggle. Many of
the union supporters and leaders have been without work for as many
as 11 months. The nine union leaders referred to in the court's
ruling must be re-instated when they arrive at Chentex at 7:00am,
Monday, April 9, 2001.
I am concerned about Chentex's motion to file a "recurso
de aclaracion." This is an obvious stall-tactic that the factory's
management is using to postpone the re-instatement of the union
leaders. Chentex can not appeal the court's ruling, as it is final
according to Nicaraguan law. I would like you to comply with the
decision of the highest court in Nicaragua and not prevent the immediate
return of the workers.
Further, I am concerned that Nien Hsing Representative, Lucas
Huang, has made the threat to close the Chentex factory. The workers
and their international support network, of which I am a part, have
demanded that your buyers such as Kohl's not lower their level of
production at Chentex. Today, I demand that Nien Hsing not cut-and-run
from Chentex. I recognize the right to organize a union as a fundamental
human right--Chentex workers must not lose their jobs for their
efforts to organize.
I thank you in advance for your cooperation with the Chentex union
and for not preventing the nine leaders from returning to their
jobs on Monday.
Sincerely,
(your name)
|