|
(More on The Saipan workers' lawsuit) March
2000, , Eight more U.S. retailers settle sweatshop suit
To all: You may have heard rumors yesterday that 6 more companies settled the
Saipan lawsuit. It's true! Now, out of the 17 original defendants, only 4 remain...the
major one being GAP Inc. Other companies that have NOT agreed to cut out ridiculous
recruitment fees that keep workers indebted to slavery; have not agreed to allow
workers to unionize; have not agreed to pay workers a living wage or pay back
wages owed to workers; and have not agreed to allow Verite (a non-profit monitoring
group) to monitor their factories are Target (merged with Dayton-Hudson), Lane
Bryant (merged with the Limited), JC. Penney and GAP Inc. Read below for more
information. Although GAP hasn't settled, this is a great victory for thousands
of workers in Saipan. Thank you to all of you who have helped in exposing the
insanely abusive conditions in Saipan sweatshops. Keep up the fight!
In solidarity, Leila Salazar Global Exchange *************************************************
Reuters
Eight more U.S. retailers settle sweatshop suit
HONOLULU - Eight more major U.S. clothing retailers have agreed to settle
a class action lawsuit which alleges sweatshop labor conditions in the
U.S. territory of Saipan, a spokesman for the plaintiffs said Tuesday.
The companies -- Calvin Klein
Inc., Jones Apparel Group, Liz Claiborne Inc., The May Department Stores Company,
Oshkosh B Gosh Inc., Sears, Roebuck and Company, Tommy Hilfiger USA Inc., and
Warnaco, Inc. -- join nine others in agreeing to pay a total of some $8 million
and adhere to a system of independent monitoring at the Saipan factories of contractors
who produce their clothing. The suit before a Hawaii court is the first
attempt to use federal racketeering laws to hold U.S. companies accountable for
mistreatment of workers in foreign-owned factories operating on U.S. soil. The
defendants, which have included a host of the best-known clothing makers in the
United States, have been accused of allowing mistreatment of thousands of workers
on Saipan, a South Pacific island territory. Earlier this month, plaintiffs
added a number of new clothing makers to the original group of defendants, indicating
that they aimed to enforce sweeping new workplace standards throughout Saipan. Global
Exchange, a San Francisco-based human rights group which is one of the plaintiffs
in the suit, hailed the new settlement agreement but blasted a number of hold-outs,
including The Gap, who have refused to sign. "It's terribly disappointing
that Gap and the other holdout defendants refuse to make a similar commitment
to end workplace abuses in Saipan," Global Exchange founding director Medea
Benjamin said. "These companies clearly have the resources and the responsibility
to clean up the factories where their clothes are made." A spokeswoman
for Gap did not immediately return a phone call seeking comment. Other
major companies which have not settled the case include J.C. Penney, Target and
Lane Bryant, a division of Limited Inc., according to the plaintiffs. The
settlement provides that in future supply contracts, retailers will require factories
to comply with strict employment standards, including guaranteeing overtime pay
for overtime work, providing safe food and drinking water, and agreeing to honor
employees' basic human rights. The settlement agreement requires court approval
and does not involve an admission of wrongdoing by the defendants. The Associated
Press Tuesday, March 28, 2000, More retailers agree to settle Saipan
garment worker lawsuits By JEAN CHRISTENSEN, Associated Press Writer HONOLULULiz
Claiborne, Calvin Klein and Tommy Hilfiger were among eight major clothing retailers
that agreed Tuesday to settle a federal class-action lawsuit brought by garment
workers in the Northern Mariana Islands. In a $5.7 million settlement filed in
U.S. District Court, the retailers agreed to pay workers who alleged they endured
sweatshop conditions and to fund an independent monitoring system to guard against
labor abuses by factory operators on the island of Saipan, which is part of the
Northern Marianas. The other retailers in the settlement were Sears, Roebuck &
Co., Jones Apparel Group, May Department Stores Co., Oshkosh B'Gosh Inc. and Warnaco
Inc. The agreement, which will be considered by a federal judge on April 25, brings
to 17 the number of retailers that have settled in the case for a total of $8
million. It does not include an admission of wrongdoing by the companies. Nine
companies, including Nordstrom Inc., J. Crew Group Inc. and Ralph Lauren, settled
claims last year. Litigation is still pending against other retailers, including
The Gap, J.C. Penney, Target and Lane Bryant, and the mostly foreign-owned garment
factories in the Western Pacific commonwealth, said Los Angeles attorney Al Meyerhoff,
who represents the plaintiffs. The latest accord represents the most significant
development in the case because the retailers account for $400 million-$500 million
of Saipan's $1 billion-a-year garment industry, he said. "We think it will
put even more pressure on the factory owners as well as on the nonsettling retailers
to adopt these reforms and move in a positive direction," Meyerhoff said.
Medea Benjamin, director of Global Exchange, a San Francisco-based human rights
group that is a plaintiff in a companion lawsuit in California state court, praised
the agreement but added, "It's terribly disappointing that Gap and the other
holdout defendants refuse to make a similar commitment to end workplace abuses
in Saipan." Kellie Leonard, a spokeswoman in San Francisco for The Gap, said:
"We believe the allegations made against our company are false and we are
committed to proving that in court." A jury trial in the case is scheduled
for next February. The Northern Mariana Islands are a U.S. possession 3,700 miles
southwest of Hawaii. The lawsuit was filed in January 1999 on behalf of
30,000 current and former garment workers, mostly women recruited from China,
the Philippines, Bangladesh and Thailand. It accuses the companies of violating
U.S. labor laws in a conspiracy with Chinese, Japanese and Korean subcontractors.
Garment workers in Saipan factories must work up to 12 hours a day, seven days
a week for less than the legal minimum wage while making clothing tagged "Made
in the USA", the lawsuit contends. The territory's commonwealth relationship
with Washington leaves control of immigration and minimum wages in local hands
while exempting Saipan's exports from U.S. duties and quotas. The settlement provides
that in future contracts, retailers will require factories to comply with strict
employment standards, including guaranteeing overtime pay, providing safe food
and drinking water, and agreeing to honor employees' basic human rights, Meyerhoff
said. "Public concern over sweatshops, particularly among young people, is
at an all-time high," he said. "Part of the reasons these companies
are settling is they'd like to be part of the solution. There's an opportunity
here not only to do the right thing in Saipan but to create a model...that others
can look to as the way to do this right." Sears spokeswoman Jan Drummond
had a simpler explanation. "The bottom line is it's a business decision,"
she said. "We looked at how long and how expensive continuing to engage in
this litigation would be weighted against the relatively small amount of business
we do in Saipan." Roberta Schuhalter Karp, Liz Claiborne vice president of
corporate affairs and general counsel, said the lawsuit "lacked merit."
"We are pleased, however, that the settlement will fund independent monitoring
in Saipan, a goal that we have long supported and that the litigation made difficult
to implement," she said. Tommy Hilfiger Corp. officials said the company
canceled its manufacturing agreements in Saipan after the lawsuit was filed, but
may resume production on the island if the court approves the settlement. |